AIYA!, elen sila omentiëlmo, ar nai eleni silar melildë
It's been a bit since you posted but if you haven't found your answer yet here's my thoughts
Which are her favourite elves? There are two Elvish languages and one might mean more to her than the other. If she likes "high elves" like Elrond or Galadriël, use Quenya. If she likes "Wood Elves" like Legolas, use Sindarin.
(you say Quenya so forgive me if it sounds patronizing but you say you are not familiar just checking)
Two translations I can think of are: ilvanya and anvanya
(il)vanya means "perfect" made from il->all/vanya>beautiful, and is cited in the lexicon here
with (an)vanya I use the intensive prefix an- meaning most. For example calimë>bright/(an)calimë> brightest (Lit. most bright), thus (an)vanya should mean "most beautiful"
One more thing is these are both general statements. if you want to say "you are the most beautiful" you just add the suffix -tyë for familiar. anvanyatyë "Lit. most beautiful You"
As for Tengwar I recommend the website Tecendil, there are different Modes with different characters and the website makes it easy, if you are writing in Quenya, use Quenya and so forth. I hope any of this helps.
edit: I'm not %100 sure but I believe you can separate the "you" in phrase making it "tyen anvanya" to correct the English reading to "you the most Beautiful"
namarië